The Acceptance of Jarh and Ta'deel if it is Done with
Explanation or Without
Meaning, if the person who does Jarh or Ta'deel, is it a must
that he must explains his position, without him giving the reasons why.
Taken from the book 'Principles in Jarh wa Ta'deel' by Shaykh
Abdul-Azeez bin Muhammad Abdul-Lateef [May Allaah have Mercy on him], (Pg.
53-56).
Shaykh Abdullah bin Abdur-Raheem al-Bukhaaree [May Allaah
Preserve him] said in explaining this;
The person doing Jarh or Ta'deel can do either of the following;
Tafseer; this is when he gives the reason for Jarh or Ta'deel
Mubham; this means there is no reason given for his Jarh or
Ta'deel
The author continues;
